Morningstar’s Mind the Gap 2026, published this August, proves an uncomfortable fact with a decade of data: a fund’s published return is never the return you earned. Across nearly 23,000 US mutual funds and ETFs, the ten-year annualised total return to the end of 2025 was 9.9%. The average dollar invested in those funds actually earned 8.7%. That 1.2-percentage-point annual gap — roughly 12% of the total return — amounts to about US$3.8 trillion lost to timing over the decade. This is not an American peculiarity. Under the MPF’s forward-pricing regime every fund switch is a blind trade, and eMPF has reduced switching to a few taps. Convenience, it turns out, is the gap’s amplifier.
The core thesis: published returns grade the manager; investor returns grade you
A published return assumes you bought on day one and never touched the position. Real investors add money after rallies and cut exposure after falls. Morningstar’s dollar-weighted calculation — effectively an internal rate of return on the average dollar — captures the timing and magnitude of every cash flow. The resulting 8.7% is the true score of the average invested dollar.
The report’s breakdown is the instructive part: the dullest funds show the narrowest gaps. US stock funds returned 13.3% in aggregate while their investors earned 12.8% — a gap of just 0.5 points, with investors capturing 97% of the total return. Allocation funds captured 92%. ETFs, by contrast, showed a wider gap (-1.6pp) than traditional open-end funds (-1.2pp) — not because ETFs are worse, but because they are easier to trade, and people do. International stock ETFs showed the widest gap in absolute terms at -2.5 percentage points.
Morningstar managing director Jeffrey Ptak’s conclusion fits in one sentence: “The less trading that allocators do, the more of their funds’ total returns they’re likely to capture.”
Translated into MPF language: eMPF is the ETF-ification of Hong Kong retirement savings — frictionless switching, and the gap follows.
Through the data: four pieces of Hong Kong evidence
Evidence one: the chairwoman’s warning. Last December, MPFA chairwoman Ayesha Macpherson Lau said plainly: try to time the market and “you can easily end up buying high and selling low.” She singled out eMPF’s convenience, warning members against a short-term trading mentality with their MPF, and said the platform would carry prompts urging members to “stop and think.” The regulator has admitted it: convenience cuts both ways.
Evidence two: 110 switches. On BCT’s MPF programme in early September, one member of a single scheme was up 32% in the first half while another was down 19% — a spread of more than 50 percentage points. The loser had switched funds 110 times in six months. Every MPF switch executes at an unknown T+1 forward price. One hundred and ten blind bets produced a result far below the scheme average.
Evidence three: the chase, in fund flows. GUM’s August report shows MPF US equity funds drawing net inflows of more than HK$12 billion year-to-date — five consecutive months of buying — while Hong Kong equity funds saw net outflows of more than HK$10 billion over the same period. Money poured into US equities after months of gains and fled Hong Kong equities in weakness. A textbook chase-and-flee snapshot.
Evidence four: leaving during a rally. This January the Hang Seng Index rose 3.98%, yet index-tracking Hong Kong equity funds suffered net outflows of HK$1.81 billion and Hong Kong equity funds lost HK$1.03 billion, with money rotating into the Default Investment Strategy — the Core Accumulation Fund took the largest single inflow at HK$931 million. Locking in profits on the way up, panicking on the way down: the market timer’s lose-lose.
The control group: Morningstar’s narrowest gaps belong to funds investors buy and forget. The MPF equivalent is the Default Investment Strategy. The Core Accumulation Fund has annualised about 7.3% since April 2017 — automatic contributions, automatic rebalancing, zero timing required — beating roughly nine in ten tinkerers.
| Published fund return | Investor’s actual return | Gap | |
|---|---|---|---|
| US market (Morningstar 2026, 10 yrs) | 9.9% | 8.7% | 1.2pp (approx. 12% of total return) |
| US stock funds | 13.3% | 12.8% | 0.5pp (97% captured) |
| ETFs (all) | 11.2% | 9.5% | 1.6pp |
| MPF local case: 110-switch member | Scheme H1 ceiling of +32% | -19% | Over 50pp |
The compounding toll: 1.2 points becomes HK$1.36 million over 30 years
Translate 1.2 percentage points into human terms. Contributing HK$5,000 a month at a nominal 7.3% annualised (roughly the Core Accumulation Fund’s return since launch) versus 6.1% (after the behaviour tax):
- 10 years: HK$880,000 vs HK$824,000 — a gap of about HK$57,000
- 20 years: HK$2.70 million vs HK$2.34 million — a gap of about HK$364,000
- 30 years: HK$6.47 million vs HK$5.12 million — a gap of about HK$1.36 million, nearly four times the average member balance of HK$343,242
At system scale: 1.2 points on roughly HK$1.705 trillion of assets is about HK$20.5 billion a year leaking through the compounding funnel. Per member: 1.2 points on HK$343,242 is about HK$4,119 a year — more than many members pay in total fund fees. The behaviour tax is the same order of magnitude as fees themselves: against a market-average fund expense ratio of 1.36%, a hard-won 0.5-point fee saving is wiped out — and then some — by a single round of performance chasing.
The blueprint: make doing nothing the system default
Defence: forward-price protection. Every MPF switch executes at an unknown T+1 price; you never know the dealing price. Impose execution discipline: split large switches into tranches, stay out of FOMC windows (late October’s 27–28 meeting is a no-switch zone), and give yourself a 72-hour cooling rule — write down the reason for any switch, then decide three days later.
Offence: rules instead of emotions. If you must reallocate, use hard-coded machinery: a 50/200-day trend filter, or rebalancing to target weights on a fixed annual date. Morningstar’s own prescription: hold the line on discretionary trades, regiment transactions through dollar-cost averaging, hold fewer and more broadly diversified funds, and automate rebalancing.
Accountability: demand disclosure. The MPFA publishes fund returns but never the money-weighted returns members actually earned. Trustees hold every member’s contribution and switching record; the calculation is trivially possible. If Morningstar can compute the gap for 23,000 US funds, Hong Kong trustees have no excuse for a blank page — step one is asking your trustee to print “your personal annualised return” on the annual statement.
This week’s checklist: (1) Log in to eMPF and count how many times you switched in the past 12 months. (2) Ask your trustee for the dollar-weighted return on the funds you hold, and compare it with the published return. (3) Write down your switching rules — the exact conditions under which you will switch — on paper, and keep it next to your screen.
The fund made 9.9% and you made 8.7%. The difference is not the manager. It is your own finger. eMPF turned switching into a few taps — and turned the gap into a few taps too. Unless you restrain the finger first.
Related articles
View all
Core CPI Misses at 0.3%: Settling the September CPI Print — October Hike Odds Double Overnight, an MPF Bond Playbook for FOMC Week
Three days ago (12 October) our CPI preview set three scenarios, with...

The 32.9% vs 11.1% Paradox: Hong Kong’s Cheapest MPF Option Holds the Smallest Balances
The Default Investment Strategy (DIS) is one of the cheapest and most...

How one MPF member turned 17 years of contributions into HK$1 million — a club of 0.3 per cent
A newspaper columnist noted an extraordinary case: a member who started work...