The 2026 Marsh CFA Institute Global Pension Index landed yesterday: Hong Kong scored 71.2, kept its B grade, ranked 16th of 55 systems worldwide and second in Asia, behind only Singapore. Applause is due — but first check who the applause is for. Split the headline number into its three sub-scores:
Integrity: 89.4, an A grade, fourth in the world — governance, regulation, member protection, world-class. Adequacy: 67.8, roughly 30th in the world. Sustainability: 62.1. The “Asia No. 2” crown sits on the regulator’s head; the retiree’s body is still scraping a pass.
First, decompose the 0.6-point rise. Last year 70.6, this year 71.2. Adequacy rose from 66.6 to 67.8 (+1.2 points, with a 40% weight), contributing +0.48 points — four-fifths of the entire gain. Integrity moved 89.2 to 89.4 (+0.05); sustainability roughly 61.9 to 62.1 (+0.07). Four-fifths of the celebrated improvement came from the design side of the system — local financial press citing the report attribute it chiefly to OECD data on the minimum pension relative to wages, not to MPF funds earning more money. Fund performance contributed nothing to the 0.6.
Then the 15-point chasm. Singapore: 82.0 overall (A, fourth globally), adequacy 82.8 — 15.0 points above Hong Kong; integrity 90.4 — just 1.0 point above. Two world-class regulators; nearly the entire gap is one question: is there enough money in the account at retirement?
The structural reason is not unjust: Singapore’s combined employer-employee contribution rate reaches 37% (on ordinary wages up to S$8,000 a month); Hong Kong’s is 10% (on relevant income up to HK$30,000, capped at HK$1,500 a side each month). A 3.7x savings rate against a 15-point adequacy gap — the arithmetic holds.
The MPFA’s provisional data from early October (to end-September) supplies the other half of the truth: since the system’s inception in December 2000, equity funds have returned 5.1% annualised net, mixed-asset funds 4.7%, bond funds 1.7%, conservative funds 1.0% — against annualised inflation of about 1.8%. The conservative fund — the system’s “safest” container — has delivered roughly -0.8% a year in real terms for 26 years. Institutional integrity scores 89.4; the safe option’s real return is negative.
Translate the scores into an account. HK$3,000 a month (employer plus employee, the full contribution at the HK$30,000 cap), for 30 years — principal HK$1.08 million:
| Annualised return | After 30 years | Note |
|---|---|---|
| 1% (the conservative-fund path) | ~HK$1.26m | Just HK$180,000 above principal |
| 4% (Singapore’s Special Account floor) | ~HK$2.06m | The compounding of a government floor |
| 5.1% (Hong Kong equity funds’ history) | ~HK$2.54m | The compounding of the market |
The gap between 1% and 5.1% is about HK$1.28 million — more than the entire principal, equal to roughly 13 years of living expenses at HK$8,000 a month. That is what 67.8 versus 82.8 looks like in a personal account. The 3.7x contribution-rate gap belongs to the system; the 1%-versus-5.1% gap is a choice every member makes.
The way out: adequacy is a choice, not a fate.
First, fund selection. The DIS Core Accumulation Fund has returned about 7.1%–7.3% annualised since its 2017 launch, with fees capped at 0.85% (about 0.77% in practice). Inside the same system, some members earn 1% and others 7% — the difference is not the system, it is the choice.
Second, the contribution rate. The TVC’s HK$60,000-a-year tax-deduction allowance is the first step from 10% toward 37% — and the only lever a member controls directly.
Third, fees. The market-average fund expense ratio is about 1.36%; DIS in practice about 0.77%. That 0.59-point gap, on HK$3,000 a month over 30 years at a 7% gross return, is worth about HK$335,000. A meaningful slice of the 67.8 is being eaten by fees.
Fourth, turn a lump sum into monthly money. The index itself recommends studying the conversion of part of retirement benefits into continuing income — Singapore has CPF LIFE (a Full Retirement Sum of S$220,400 pays about S$1,780 a month for life); Hong Kong hands you the lump sum and walks away. The MPFA chairman’s own annuity arithmetic: HK$1.53 million converts to HK$8,000–9,000 a month for life. The last mile of adequacy is not how much money there is, but whether money arrives every month — a step Hong Kong’s system has not yet taken for you.
71.2 deserves its B. But inside the B, the 89.4 belongs to the regulator and the 67.8 belongs to you. Wear the crown if you like — the bill is yours to pay, and its figures start being written the moment you choose your funds.
Related articles
View all
Core CPI Misses at 0.3%: Settling the September CPI Print — October Hike Odds Double Overnight, an MPF Bond Playbook for FOMC Week
Three days ago (12 October) our CPI preview set three scenarios, with...

Behind the HK$1.67 Trillion Record: The Chairwoman’s 7.3% Is Both a Report Card and a Fee X-Ray
On 30 August 2026, MPFA Chairwoman Lau did something unusual: she wrote the...

Replacing the MPF with a 7.5% central provident fund? Unpacking the proposal and the five-pillar debate
In November 2017, a political party proposed a Central Provident Fund to...