跳至主內容 Skip to main content

The Day US Equity Funds Overtook Hong Kong’s: HK$12.1 Billion of Momentum Buying, or the End of Home Bias?

2026-10-19
Marcus Tang
Marcus Tang

Track 1 Data X-Ray | 2026-10-19

On 7 October, GUM released its third-quarter MPF scorecard, and one line redrew the map: US equity funds now account for a larger share of total MPF assets than Hong Kong equity funds — the latter sitting at roughly 22% of the system.

Thirty-one days earlier, this column documented the “home bias tax” using August Lipper data: Korea equity funds up 71.6% year-to-date against Hong Kong equity funds at just 0.2%. A month later, the bill has been settled: Hong Kong equity funds have seen net outflows of over HK$10 billion year-to-date, while US equity funds absorbed roughly HK$12.1 billion, Asian equity funds HK$3.7 billion and Japanese equity funds HK$1.2 billion — about HK$17 billion combined. Home bias has been executed by the numbers.

But the “awakening” narrative does not survive a timestamp check. That HK$12.1 billion arrived after the rally. US equity funds are up 10.4% year-to-date; Hong Kong equity funds are down 3.8% — the 14.2 percentage-point gap was already printed in the scorecard before the money moved. And in the very same scorecard, GUM’s own chief investment officer warned that US equities currently have “limited room for error.” Members listened — and kept buying. US equity funds took in HK$3.14 billion in September alone, the sixth straight month of inflows; then September closed at minus 1.47% for the system, costing the average member HK$5,060. The momentum tax was settled on the spot.

Through the numbers: two calibers, one flow

Reconcile the two readings before they start fighting. GUM’s strategy director used the Hong Kong-only caliber — about 22%. The South China Morning Post, quoting MPF Ratings, uses Hong Kong-plus-mainland-China combined, which still exceeds one-third of total assets. Both can be true: Hong Kong alone has been overtaken; Hong Kong plus China together remains the system’s largest block. What members are actually abandoning is the word “Hong Kong.”

Three cross-checks on the flows (as of 30 September):

DimensionFigureSource
US equity funds, net inflows YTD~HK$12.1 billionGUM Q3 scorecard (2026-10-07)
HK equity funds (incl. trackers), net outflows YTD>HK$10 billionSame
Asian / Japan equity funds, net inflows YTD~HK$3.7bn / ~HK$1.2bnSame
HK + China equities, net outflows in Q3~HK$8.04 billionMPF Ratings (2026-10-15)
US equities, net inflows in Q3>HK$8.14 billionSame
US equity funds, net inflows in September~HK$3.14 billion (6th straight month)GUM September data (2026-09-24)
Forecast 2026 fund-switching volumeHK$74.7 billion (+25.5% y/y, 5-year high)GUM strategy director (2026-10-07)

The return comparison is harsher still: Asian equity funds lead year-to-date at +24.3%, Japan at +20.76%, the US at +10.4%, and Hong Kong equity funds sit at the bottom at minus 3.8%. Put plainly, members sold this year’s worst category and chased this year’s above-average one — a textbook momentum trade, gift-wrapped as “diversification.”

The compounding cost: picking the wrong market equals a wasted year

Translate 14.2 percentage points into human terms: the average member’s balance is HK$338,950 (MPF Ratings’ final September figure). Multiply by 14.2% and you get about HK$48,100 — equal to 9.6 months of HK$5,000 monthly contributions. Pick the wrong market for one year, work a year for nothing.

The timing tax is more poisonous. The HK$3.14 billion that chased US equity funds in September bought in just before the system’s minus 1.47% month. Morningstar’s Mind the Gap 2026 puts the behaviour tax at 1.2 percentage points a year — under an illustrative HK$5,000-a-month, 7% gross return simulation, that gap compounds to about HK$1.36 million over 30 years, nearly four times the average balance. Momentum buying is not a one-off tuition fee; it is a subscription that auto-renews every year.

The MPFA’s response deserves to be read word for word: monthly figures from commercial firms are “very broad-brush numbers,” the regulator said, urging members not to view MPF through a “short-term trading lens” lest they “buy high and sell low.” The HK$74.7 billion switching wave is exactly what the regulator warned against.

The fix: discipline after the crossover

US equity funds overtaking Hong Kong’s is not itself bad — home bias was always a tax. The problem is how the money got there. Four rules for switching:

  1. Chase fees, not winners. Half the energy behind HK$74.7 billion of switching would do better pointed at the market’s cheapest tracker funds: same index exposure, a 0.46 percentage-point fee gap, and roughly HK$447,000 of difference over 30 years (illustrative HK$5,000/month, 7% gross).
  2. Anchor to neutral, not momentum. The DIS Core Accumulation Fund has annualised about 7.1% since its April 2017 launch, with its statutory 60/40 mix rebalancing itself — doing nothing has beaten nine out of ten momentum chasers.
  3. Observe the no-go calendar. Switching executes at T+1/T+2 forward pricing: no instructions during the 27–28 October FOMC meeting, the 3 November US midterms, or the late-November MSCI review effective week.
  4. Treat expert warnings as signals. When the CIO says US equities have “limited room for error” and members buy anyway, history sides with the professional more often than with the flow.

The end of the home bias tax should be the start of allocation discipline, not the start of momentum trading. The day US equity funds overtook Hong Kong’s is worth remembering — but remember it by asking why you never moved before that day.

    funds to compare