跳至主內容 Skip to main content

Experts vs the Crowd: Q4’s First-Month Scorecard — Greater China Fell 9.8%, and the Winning Category Was the One Nobody Tipped

2026-11-20
Marcus Tang
Marcus Tang

Track 1 Data X-Ray | 6 November 2026, 14:00

The Core Proposition

Before the fourth quarter opened, two sets of answers were on the table. The experts’ set: in its third-quarter report on 7 October, GUM’s chief investment officer Christopher Lau Gar-hung laid out a menu by risk tier — global equity funds for the high-risk tier, with an eye on artificial-intelligence beneficiaries among US equity funds; the Default Investment Strategy’s Core Accumulation Fund for the middle tier; and MPF conservative funds for the low-risk tier, where short-dated money-market instruments were yielding roughly 3 to 4 per cent in a high-rate environment with no currency risk. The crowd’s set was written in real money: GUM’s September flow data showed US equity funds taking member inflows for a sixth consecutive month, more than HK$15.2 billion net year to date; Hong Kong equity funds, trackers included, had bled roughly HK$10.97 billion net over the same period; and MPF Ratings’ third-quarter basis agreed — Hong Kong and China equities saw about HK$8.04 billion of net outflows, some 90 per cent of all net outflows, US equities took in more than HK$8.14 billion, and the Default Investment Strategy absorbed close to 60 per cent of net inflows.

October’s final numbers, settled on 4 November, allow the first month to be scored. The experts’ menu beat the market at every tier (the GUM composite fell 2.6 per cent, a loss of HK$8,677 per member), with losses rising exactly in step with the risk label. The crowd went one-for-two: the US bet paid, the Asia chase lost 8.2 per cent in a month, and the month’s biggest winning category, other equities, up 8.6 per cent, was tipped by no expert menu and chased by no large flow. One irony completes the picture: in September, the largest fixed-income outflow came out of conservative funds — and in October the only asset class to post a positive return was fixed income, up 0.4 per cent.

The context: full portability Phase One opens in 31 days, on 21 December, for roughly 1 million employees who joined the workforce or changed jobs on or after 1 May 2025. The menus and league tables scored here are exactly what those new members will read before choosing a trustee. Learning how to score a menu comes before following one.

X-Ray: the October Scorecard, Translated into HK$250,000

Call or flowSource and dateOctober resultOn HK$250,000
Experts, high-risk tier: global equity fundsGUM menu, 7 OctInterim (to 20 Oct) -0.7%About -HK$1,750
Experts, watch list: US equity fundsGUM menu, 7 OctInterim +0.6% (year to date +11.1%); North American funds on the MPFGo board rose 1.21% to 1.38% for the full monthAbout +HK$1,500
Experts, middle tier: Core Accumulation FundGUM menu, 7 OctFull month -0.9% (year to date +6.3%, best of the mixed-asset categories)-HK$2,250
Experts, low-risk tier: conservative funds / fixed incomeGUM menu, 7 OctFixed income was the month’s only positive asset class, +0.4%; global bond funds +1.5%About +HK$1,000
The crowd’s biggest bet: US equity fundsMore than HK$15.2bn net inflow year to datePositive against the market, as aboveAbout +HK$1,500
The crowd’s second chase: Asian equity fundsSecond-largest September net inflow categoryFull month -8.2%; the Korean equity category fell more than 16%-HK$20,500
The crowd’s exit: Hong Kong equity fundsRoughly HK$10.97bn net outflow year to dateFull month -7.6% (index trackers -5.4%)Avoided -HK$19,000
The third quarter’s “resilient” category: Greater China equity fundsYear to date +12.8% at end-Q3, ahead of US equities at +10.4%Full month -9.8%, the worst category-HK$24,500
Nobody’s pick: other equity fundsAbsent from expert menus and major flows alikeFull month +8.6%, the best category+HK$21,500

Three readings. First, the experts’ menu did not fail — but it won on structure, not foresight. The three tiers are simply diversification and de-risking written as a list, and in a falling month each tier delivered its label: GUM’s equity fund index fell 4.0 per cent, mixed assets fell 2.2 per cent, fixed income rose 0.4 per cent. Lau attributed October to doubts over whether artificial-intelligence capital spending will pay, with tech-heavy Asian markets hit first. Two of his fourth-quarter calls remain unsettled — a December Federal Reserve rate hike he rated highly likely, and a Hang Seng Index trending around 25,000 points into year-end — and this scorecard settles only the first month of three.

Second, the crowd’s verdict turns on which square of the board the money chased. The US leg deserves its credit: another HK$3.14 billion arrived in September alone, and October paid it a positive return. The Asia leg followed the league table: Asian equity funds ended the third quarter as the year’s champions at +24.3 per cent, took the second-largest September inflows, then fell 8.2 per cent in October, narrowing their year-to-date gain to 14.1 per cent and surrendering the year’s crown to Japanese equity funds at +19.3 per cent. Greater China was the sharpest flip: held up by Taiwanese semiconductor holdings, it ended September up 12.8 per cent year to date, ahead of US equities — then fell 9.8 per cent in a month, leaving it up only about 1.7 per cent year to date on desk arithmetic, a swing from leader to laggard of roughly nine percentage points. A league table records the past; a flow buys the future; between the two sits a one-month category gap of 10.4 percentage points (Greater China -9.8 per cent against the US interim +0.6 per cent).

Third, the winning category needs its own X-ray. On MPF Ratings’ basis, roughly 90 per cent of “other equities” is one healthcare fund’s solo performance, as this morning’s settlement piece detailed. It is not an answer anyone can copy; it is a reminder that a category name is not a diversification count, and a one-month champion can be a single fund.

The Compounding Cost: One Month’s Gap Equals Seventeen Years of Fees

Translate the 10.4-percentage-point one-month gap into money. On a HK$250,000 balance it is HK$26,000. On the average balance of HK$330,861 (MPF Ratings, end-October) it is closer to HK$34,000. Now set it against the fee line: the average fund expense ratio across the market is about 1.36 per cent, against roughly 0.77 per cent actually charged on the Default Investment Strategy — a gap of 0.59 percentage points, worth about HK$1,475 a year on the same HK$250,000. One month of picking the wrong category therefore cost roughly what 17.6 years of the fee gap would. The two numbers are not the same kind of thing, and that is the point: the category gap is a dice roll, with no memory and no promise about next month; the fee gap is a contract, deducted every year and never refunded. On an illustrative HK$5,000 a month at a 7 per cent gross return, compounded monthly, 0.59 percentage points is worth about HK$26,000 over ten years, HK$160,000 over twenty and HK$559,000 over thirty. Roll dice for thirty years and the expected value does not improve; sign the cheaper contract and the HK$559,000 is locked in, as far as arithmetic can lock anything in.

There is also an execution layer. GUM strategy and investment analysis director Wan Tin-fai projected in the third-quarter report that member switching in 2026 will reach HK$74.7 billion, a five-year high — there have never been so many switchers. But MPF trades on forward pricing, struck at T+1 or T+2 prices the member cannot see when instructing, and a cross-trustee transfer spends one to two weeks in transit, during which 2 per cent on HK$250,000 is about HK$5,000. Greater China’s 9.8 per cent fall happened inside roughly four weeks: a member who acted on the third-quarter league table in late September was still in transit while the price fell. The year of record switching is also the year category rotation outran settlement speed. Those are not two facts; they are the same fact read twice.

The Breakout: Score the Scorecards, Do Not Trade Them

First, demand a settlement date on every menu. Fourth-quarter calls get judged at the end of the fourth quarter: this scorecard is one-third of the evidence, and Lau’s remaining calls — the December hike and the index level — expire in December. Any menu without a stated date and a stated yardstick is marketing, not analysis.

Second, separate the two questions. “Which category won October” was unknowable in advance; single-month category gaps above ten percentage points are volatility, not information. “What does my balance pay every year” is knowable today: check each fund’s expense ratio against the two anchors, the market average of about 1.36 per cent and the Default Investment Strategy at about 0.77 per cent. Allocate research time in that proportion — nine parts fees and fund menus, one part scorecards.

Third, if you act, move structure, not rankings. The only approach that behaved as labelled at all three risk tiers in October was the diversified one — global equity, Core Accumulation, conservative. The deepest losses sat in single-region, single-supply-chain concentration: an Asia allocation is in large part a semiconductor cycle bet, as the Korean category’s fall of more than 16 per cent in a single month demonstrates. Size it as that bet, not as “Asian diversification”.

Fourth, keep the execution discipline unchanged. Place no discretionary instruction in the Federal Reserve week of 8 to 9 December. Decide any trustee move on settled figures and fee tables, not on a single month’s league table. And for Phase One members: settle your target trustee and fund menu before the gate opens on 21 December, so that what you execute that week is a written list, not an impulse in front of a rankings page. October’s HK$8,677 per member is already history, and no scorecard changes it. What can still change is whether the next instruction you place is driven by a contract or by a table.

Sources:
  • GUM third-quarter MPF market analysis report (7 October 2026, via Hong Kong Commercial Daily, Sing Tao Headline and etnet)
  • GUM September fund-flow release (16 October 2026, via Hong Kong Commercial Daily)
  • MPF Ratings, third-quarter 2026 MPF asset-class fund-flow summary (15 October 2026)
  • GUM October MPF performance release (4 November 2026, via am730 and Sing Tao Headline)
  • MPF Ratings October settlement (4 November 2026)
  • MPFGo October fund rankings (to 28 October, via Ming Pao). Interim figures are labelled with their cut-off dates in the text
  • the Greater China year-to-date figure is desk arithmetic from GUM’
  • s published numbers. Illustrative calculations assume HK$5,000 a month, a 7 per cent gross return and an unchanged fee structure. Past performance is not an indicator of future performance
  • this article does not constitute a recommendation of any fund or trustee.

    Related articles

    Kay Choi

    強積金新聞記者 主責:強積金政策、受託人動態,以及與成員切身相關的基金數據。 Kay Choi 加入 MPF.hk...

    GUM: MPF gains HK$4,933 per member in August, HK$25,335 year-to-date

    GUM's August MPF report: composite index +1.5%, average gain HK$4,933 per...

    funds to compare