Early MPF Withdrawal: Which Reasons Were Rejected in the 2011 Consultation?
2011-12-19
On 19 December 2011, the MPFA published its consultation paper on early withdrawal of MPF benefits. Beyond the proposed new “terminal illness” ground, the most revealing section was a list of what had been considered — and rejected: which reasons were once on the table, and why they didn’t make it.
Which reasons were rejected for early MPF withdrawal?
The 2011 consultation paper rejected five grounds for early withdrawal: critical illness, a dependant’s critical illness, unemployment, home ownership and education. The MPFA’s reasoning: MPF exists solely for retirement savings; critical illnesses are not always fatal and public hospitals are already cheap; the unemployed should find work or seek CSSA; home purchases and education each had their own government subsidies and should not drain retirement money.
Rejected grounds and the MPFA’s reasoning (2011 consultation paper)
| Ground once considered | Why the MPFA rejected it |
|---|---|
| Critical illness | Not always fatal — patients who recover still need retirement savings; public hospitals provide low-cost care |
| Dependant’s critical illness | MPF is for the member’s own retirement savings, not a family medical fund |
| Unemployment | Hard to define “financial hardship due to unemployment”; without vetting, members would withdraw at every job loss and have nothing left |
| Home ownership | Government already had home-ownership assistance; low contribution rates meant young members could rarely save enough for a down payment; the law barred MPF from investing directly in property |
| Education | Subsidised student finance schemes already covered kindergarten through university |
The one ground that got through: terminal illness
All five were rejected; only “terminal illness” was proposed as a new sixth early-withdrawal ground. The MPFA’s logic: for the terminally ill, saving for life after 65 had “lost its meaning” — the one case that warranted an exception. That 2011 stance became a frequently cited starting point in every later debate about early withdrawal.
The full early-withdrawal rules are explained at the MPF education hub.
Related articles
View all
Two convicted for falsely claiming permanent departure to withdraw MPF
This article is a rewrite of a report from August 2013. Two workers who...
MPFA Studies Early MPF Withdrawal for Serious Illness, Phased Payouts After 65
In July 2011 the MPFA revealed it was studying two relaxations to MPF...
Think twice before tapping MPF savings for a first home: what can HK$180,000 do against a HK$2 million down payment?
The MPFA was studying whether to allow early MPF withdrawals for first-time...